In a series of shiurim, Rabbi Sholom Ber Levin, head of the Lubavitch library and author of numerous seforim, explained why according to the Alter Rebbe an eruv in Crown Heights would not be kosher .
The halachos of eruvin are very complex. A series of shiurim on this topic was recently given at Empire Shtiebel by Rabbi Sholom Ber Levin, chief librarian of the Lubavitch library and author of numerous seforim.
The halacha is that one cannot enclose a reshus harabim (public domain) using a tzuras hapesach (a string eruv), as it requires actual walls. Rabbi Levin explained why, according to the Alter Rebbe’s opinion, large cities with a population of 600,000 inhabitants or more are considered a reshus harabim. Based on this, a tzuras hapesach would not permit carrying in Crown Heights, a neighborhood in Brooklyn.
We bring you seven shiurim on the topic given over by Rabbi Levin along with a pamphlet he recently published on this topic. Each shiur comes along with a handout.
It should be noted that the Rebbe himself expressed opposition on a number of occasions to building city eruvin. Here are two examples:
- In the year 5742/1982, the Rebbe wrote to Rabbonim in Melbourne, Australia:
“My opinion is well known that in this generation a recognized man or organization which makes an eruv and knows that it will eventually become publicized – this is a dreadful stumbling block. For it is impossible that there won’t be one Shabbos when the eruv will be possul – and having become used to carrying on Shabbos all announcements and notices that the eruv is possul and that it is forbidden to carry will not help to stop people from carrying. An eruv should therefore only be made in secrecy.”
2. Another response was given in 5745/1985 to Rabbi Mordechai Zev Gutnick of Melbourne, who asked whether to build an eruv in Doncaster, Melbourne. The Rebbe’s response was copied and relayed by the secretary R’ Binyomin Klein a”h:
“To build an eruv – It is well known the complex discussions in this. And what is forcing him to enter into all of this?!”
For Rabbi Levin’s recently released teshura on this topic, click here.
In keeping in line with the Rabbonim's policies for websites, we do not allow comments. However, our Rabbonim have approved of including input on articles of substance (Torah, history, memories etc.)
We appreciate your feedback. If you have any additional information to contribute to this article, it will be added below.
גם הו”ל חוברת לבאר כל הנושא הזה בכתב, והוא מופיע כאן:
Can I download this just in audio to my phone?
Why can’t it be one long video?
תלמוד ירושלמי עירובין
פרק ח דף נד עמוד ב
ריש לקיש אמר לעולם אין רשות הרבים עד שתהא
מפולשת מסוף העולם ועד סופו.
מיחלף שיטת ריש לקיש דאמר אין רשות הרבים בעולם הזה אלא לעתיד לבוא שנאמר (ישעיהו מ) כל גיא ינשא.
תורת מנחם חלק יד עמוד 265
הרי בזמן הזה שאין לנו רשות הרבים כפי שפוסק רבינו הזקן. רק לעתיד לבוא יהיה רשות הרבים
ר מנשה קליין זצ”ל במשנה הלכות
שאדמו”ר מליובאוויטש אומר שאין רשות הרבים בעיירות גדולות וברוקלין
משנה הלכות חלק שמיני