Nevertheless, the total indifference (if I may say so) that exists today among the frumer parties in Israel (and actually everywhere), regarding the issue of Pikuach Nefesh as spelled out by the Rebbe, defies all boundaries, and if I dare to say so, there are also many in Lubavitch who may not have it clear. Therefore, in a report that is targeted for the Lubavitch reader, and especially in such an issue, the Rebbe’s opinion should be voiced and come through clearly.

As I wrote initially, I’m fully appreciative of this writers work, and my intention is only to bring this point to her attention, and I’m sure she’ll deal with it responsibly.

Our actions here in Crown Heights or wherever you are have an effect on Eretz Yisroel and can bring baout that Good News we are all looking for.

These posts show us how much we need to shape ourselves up so that it has positive effects on Eretz Yisroel and Yidden worldwide.

And regarding the point of articles not sounding posotive when theres little good news, I don’t understand, you want people to go on CNN or the other C to check news!? Chas VeSholom. Only use Anash.org for news.

Presumably most people reading this website are familiar with the Rebbe’s view based on siman 329 in Shulchan Aruch but perhaps it would be kedai that in addition to publishing these reports, an additional feature outlining the Rebbe’s view be published as well because most people are not aware of the basis of it and can mistakenly assume that Chabad is another right wing, pro Zionist organization R”L.

Just a thought. Thank you for doing what you do.

This is in reference to the written above about establishing a Palestinian state in Judah and Samaria as being against Jewish law in giving away biblical jewish land.

The Rebbe’s opinion is clearly that this is against Jewish law of Pikuach Nefesh and that limiting it only to the claim for biblical Jewish land, undermines the claim and pronouncement about Pikuach Nefesh.

In our time today when the truce in the Rebbe’s words about Pikuach Nefesh has proven itself beyond all doubt, and at the same time, there isn’t a single voice anywhere (besides in Lubavitch) that is even mentioning the Rebbe’s opinion, the open Chilul Hashem – and open Chilul Pikucah Nefesh of Yidden – transpassses all limits.

This is only exacerbated when in a news report that targets the Lubavitcher reader, the voice of Bnei Akiva and Mizrachi (with all the validity that it may have) about biblical land is being voiced, and not that of the Rebbe about Pikuach Nefesh. [The added few words about risk of terror etc, doesn’t help].

All this is being written with the fullest respect for the wonderful work of the writer, and I’m sure it will dealt with the fullest responsibility. Thank you.