Comments on: Rabbi Levine Speaks Out About the Rebbe’s Eruv Letter

By: ששים ריבוא בעיר

ששים ריבוא בעיר — Tue, 25 Oct 2022 08:58:57 +0000

במענה לשאלתו הנ”ל, אסתפק בלשון דבריו של הרבי בשיחה הנ”ל:
“כאשר נשתנה המצב – מאיזו סיבה שהיא – ויש עיירות שעוברים בהן ששים ריבוא בכל יום, יש להן דין רשות הרבים גמורה מן התורה בלי שום פקפוק”.

וכן בלשונו של אדמו”ר הזקן בשלחן ערוך שלו סי’ שנז ס”ז:
“עיר גדולה שיש בה ס’ ריבוא”.

By: Even those who do will continue to carry out of habit

Even those who do will continue to carry out of habit — Mon, 24 Oct 2022 21:14:29 +0000

While some wanted to doubt/debate the Rebbe’s statement that “even those who do will continue to carry out of habit”, the clear evidence was presented this past Shabbos in front of 770, where many mistakenly carried out of habit, after they got accustomed to carrying from 770 to the tent, forgetting that the מחיצות were moved and that for Shabbos Bereishis it could only be done from the back doors of 770!

By: correction

correction — Mon, 24 Oct 2022 16:41:31 +0000

In reply to Rabbi. On the audio, the relevant part of the sicha begins at 28.35 minuts

By: Dc

Dc — Mon, 24 Oct 2022 15:54:50 +0000

I don’t know anything about this topic but here’s what I don’t understand from the article
1. From the maane and sicha you see that today practically there is a reshus horabim d’oraisa and common enough for the Rebbe to add it in. I don’t see the jump to saying that every city with 600,000 is a r”h deoraisa (besides for Rabbi levin bringing that it’s clear from many places in the alter Rebbe, which should be enough without the maane)
There are places that have a street with 600,000 people passing every day, for example oxford street in London.
2. Based on this why is yerushalim not a reshus harabim d’oraisa? Or is it?

I obviously listen to what the rabonim pasken and not questioning their psak but if Rabbi levin is sharing this with the public to prove that this was the Rebbes shita, I don’t see it from this article.

By: Rabbi

Rabbi — Mon, 24 Oct 2022 07:53:34 +0000

In this sicha https://ashreinu.app/player?parentEvent=4637&event=4641

20:05

The rebbe talks about ששים רבוא בוקעים בו
That now days there are cities that ששים רבוא בוקעים בו

By: Member of anash

Member of anash — Mon, 24 Oct 2022 07:37:50 +0000

The sicha about the eiruv

https://ashreinu.app/player?parentEvent=4637&event=4641

By: Member of Anash

Member of Anash — Mon, 24 Oct 2022 01:49:00 +0000

In reply to 12 Tammuz sicha. Correct, the audio is much more clear than the printed version from Lehak. It is quite clear that we are talking about a actual place which is a Reshus Horabim. In this letter, it becomes clear once again, that according to the Rebbe, there is a place which is a Reshus Horabim, and in such a place one cannot even put up an Eruv secretly. The Rebbe was obviously not discussing Tokyo or Honolulu. And it must be clear, that this is a Letter which is addressing a matter LeMaaseh.

By: 5745

5745 — Mon, 24 Oct 2022 01:04:01 +0000

In reply to Wondering. The article says clearly

By: Wondering

Wondering — Mon, 24 Oct 2022 00:37:50 +0000

from which year is that sicha?

By: 12 Tammuz sicha

12 Tammuz sicha — Sun, 23 Oct 2022 22:40:46 +0000

That sicha is already very decisive if you listen to the audio of the Rebbe saying it. This letter just confirms it clearly.

Thank you for posting