Comments on: Eruv in New York and Other Large Cities https://anash.org/eruv-in-new-york-and-other-large-cities/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=eruv-in-new-york-and-other-large-cities News, Views, Inspiration Fri, 14 Jul 2023 02:38:12 +0000 hourly 1 By: A metropolis is much worse https://anash.org/eruv-in-new-york-and-other-large-cities/#comment-25213 Fri, 14 Jul 2023 02:38:12 +0000 https://anash.org/?p=641348#comment-25213 In reply to Rebbe’s answer.

That answer is relevant even for a medium sized town discussed in the last column. In a case where an eruv is halachically possible, the Rebbe held that it should not be made public due to the problems that can result.

This column is discussing a situation when an eruv is simply NOT POSSIBLE. If the area is a reshus horabbim min haTorah, then you need real walls, which obviously you don’t have. That is why the rabbonim say that “there is no eruv” since it is simply not valid!

]]> By: Rebbe's answer https://anash.org/eruv-in-new-york-and-other-large-cities/#comment-25210 Fri, 14 Jul 2023 02:22:51 +0000 https://anash.org/?p=641348#comment-25210 מפורסמת דעתי שבדורנו זה איש או ארגון שמתחשבים אתו העושה עירוב ויודע שסוף סוף יתפרסם הדבר – הרי זה תקלה איומה, כי אי אפשר שלא יארע שבת קודש אחד והעירוב פסול – וע”פ טבע שיתרגלו פעמים אחדים בהוצאה בשבת
קודש לא תועיל כל הכרזה והודעה שהעירוב נפסל ואסור וכו’ שיפסיקו להוציא

ואין לעשות עירוב אלא בסודיות

]]> By: Which "famous answer"? https://anash.org/eruv-in-new-york-and-other-large-cities/#comment-25200 Thu, 13 Jul 2023 19:42:20 +0000 https://anash.org/?p=641348#comment-25200 Which “famous answer” are you refering to?

]]> By: Umm https://anash.org/eruv-in-new-york-and-other-large-cities/#comment-25198 Thu, 13 Jul 2023 19:12:35 +0000 https://anash.org/?p=641348#comment-25198 Why is the famous answer of the Rebbe not even mentioned?!

]]>